FREE! Wardrobe Checklist Download + Weekly Newsletter 
Thanksgiving is one of those holidays where the vibe is equal parts cozy and celebratory. Like so many of us, I keep it pretty casual but still want to feel festive and put together. Between our Friendsgiving dinner on Wednesday and Thanksgiving Day with family, I always reach for my favorite jeans and a top or sweater that feels comfortable but still special.
If you also spend your holiday in denim, this edit is for you. I rounded up a mix of comfortable, polished tops and sweaters that pair perfectly with jeans—pieces that look great in photos, feel good all day, and still capture the spirit of the season.
Whether you’re hosting, traveling, or keeping things simple at home, here are my favorite Thanksgiving tops and sweaters to wear with jeans this year.
Lands’ End Fuzzy Turtleneck Lantern Sleeve Jacquard Sweater
If you love a classic Fair Isle but want something that feels a little fresher, this Lands’ End Fuzzy Turtleneck Lantern Sleeve Jacquard Sweater is such a good pick. The Rich Ginger Brown Fair Isle colorway feels perfect for Thanksgiving. It’s warm, cozy, and festive without being over the top.
It’s currently $109.95, on sale for $54.97 with code STORM, and available in regular and plus sizes, XS–3X. I love it with dark-wash jeans and cognac boots for an easy, pulled-together look that still feels comfortable enough for cooking, traveling, or hosting all day.
Evereve Lottie Cardigan
Evereve always has great unique separates, and this Lottie Cardigan is such a standout piece. The neutral plaid is striking and gives a fresh twist to a classic pattern.
It’s $139 and available in sizes XS through XL. I love it styled simply with a white tank and your favorite black jeans for an effortless Thanksgiving look that feels polished but comfortable.
Shop the Evereve Lottie Cardigan
J.Crew Cable-Knit Crewneck Sweater
I just bought this Cable-Knit Crewneck Sweater from J.Crew and wore it in Boston last weekend. It’s one of those easy, classic pieces that goes with everything. I took the small, and it fit well, though J.Crew sizing can be all over the place. I’m a small in this, but in their more fitted cashmere sweaters I’m more comfortable in a large.
It’s $118 and comes in several colors. I went with Ivory Lace, but the green and Mulberry are both rich and seasonal without feeling too on the nose. Pair it with medium or dark-wash jeans and gold hoops for a timeless Thanksgiving look.
Shop the J.Crew Cable-Knit Sweater
Tuckernuck Cream and Tan Collared Short Sleeve Phil Sweater
If you live in a warmer part of the country, this short sleeve Cream and Tan Collared Phil Sweater from Tuckernuck is such a sweet and chic option. It feels seasonal without being heavy, and the mix of cream and tan makes it easy to pair with denim in any wash.
It’s $128 and available in sizes XXS through XXL. I love how polished it looks with straight-leg jeans and loafers, but it would be just as pretty dressed up with a skirt for a more elevated Thanksgiving look.
Shop the Tuckernuck Phil Sweater
Tuckernuck Merlot Embroidered Floral Frankie Sweater
I flipping love this one. Tuckernuck does such a great job of taking a basic and elevating it. The Merlot Embroidered Floral Frankie Sweater is beautifully made, with a rich color that feels so right for Thanksgiving. The sweet puff sleeve and detailed knit give it just enough personality without feeling fussy.
It’s $158 and available in sizes XXS through XXL. This might actually be what I end up wearing this year. It’s cozy, pretty, and looks perfect with dark-wash jeans and simple gold jewelry.
Shop the Tuckernuck Frankie Sweater
Dudley Stephens Greenpoint Turtleneck in Terry Fleece
Dudley Stephens makes the coziest fleece tops that somehow look super elevated, and this Greenpoint Turtleneck in Terry Fleece is a perfect example. The ivory and camel stripe feels sophisticated but still cozy, striking that ideal casual chic balance we all want for Thanksgiving.
It’s $158 and available in sizes XS through XXL. I’d pair it with slim-straight jeans that skim your ankle and these loafers from Rothy’s in the Cortado shade for a relaxed but polished look that feels right at home all weekend long.
Shop the Dudley Stephens Greenpoint Turtleneck
Shop the Rothy’s Penny Loafers
Banana Republic Cotton-Alpaca-Merino Henley Sweater
The color of this Cotton-Alpaca-Merino Henley Sweater from Banana Republic is stunning. The Toasted Spice Brown feels rich and warm, perfect for fall gatherings and Thanksgiving dinner. The button detail keeps it casual while the texture gives it a polished feel.
It’s $119.99, with an extra 20% off at checkout, and available in sizes XXS through XXL. Style it with classic jeans and simple gold hoops for a relaxed but refined outfit that works for everything from Friendsgiving to dessert with family.
Shop the Banana Republic Henley Sweater
Banana Republic Boxy Cotton Poplin Shirt
This Boxy Cotton Poplin Shirt from Banana Republic is a great option if you prefer something a little more structured than a sweater. It’s tailored yet casual, and the high-low hem means you don’t have to fuss with tucking or adjusting throughout the day.
It’s $64.99, with an extra 20% off at checkout, and available in regular and petite fits. I love the Brown Stripe for fall. Pair it with your favorite straight-leg jeans and loafers for a clean, classic Thanksgiving look.
Shop the Banana Republic Poplin Shirt
Thanksgiving style is all about balance, feeling pulled together without sacrificing comfort. Whether you love a cozy sweater, a polished button-down, or something in between, these pieces make it easy to look and feel your best while spending time with family and friends.
I’ll keep adding new finds over the next few weeks, so be sure to check back as the holidays get closer.
Leave a Comment