Home » Etcetera » Your Black Turtleneck Is More Interesting Than You Think: 3 Ways to Wear It This Holiday Season

Your Black Turtleneck Is More Interesting Than You Think: 3 Ways to Wear It This Holiday Season

I think we overlook the simplest things in our closets because we’re so used to wearing them the same way. Take a black turtleneck. Most of us have one, but how often do we style it beyond the most basic outfits?

With the holidays here, I wanted to show you how much more you can do with one once you start mixing colors, playing with proportions, and adding a few interesting accessories. So I’ve put together three black turtleneck outfits: one for everyday, something festive with a green dupioni skirt, and a slightly unexpected option for a night out.

A quick style note before we get started: For these outfits, you want a turtleneck with a smooth finish rather than a ribbed knit or anything with noticeable texture. It should follow the shape of your body without being skin-tight, close enough that you feel the fabric but loose enough to move comfortably.

You don’t need the exact turtleneck I’m featuring. If you already have one that fits the description, use it. And if you’re looking for something new, I’ve rounded up three options at different price points in my black turtleneck Splurge, Spend, Save guide.

Three ways to style a black turtleneck for the holidays: with MOTHER straight-leg jeans and a brown Quince wool blazer, with a green Tuckernuck dupioni skirt, and with bronze metallic Banana Republic Factory pants

Look 1: A Black Turtleneck With Jeans and a Brown Blazer

Black turtleneck with MOTHER Mid Rise Dazzler Ankle jeans, a brown Quince Italian wool oversized blazer, Margaux Pointe flats in Dune and Black, a Quince black clutch and a J.Crew tortoiseshell headband
Ripley Rader Black Modal Turtleneck, $128 | Quince Italian Wool Oversized Blazer, $100 | MOTHER The Mid Rise Dazzler Ankle Jeans, $238 | Margaux The Pointe in Dune and Black, $224 (reg. $280) | Quince Naomi Leather Clutch, $130 | J.Crew Tortoise Headband, $29.50

For our first look, we’re starting with classic straight-leg jeans from MOTHER. These are The Mid Rise Dazzler Ankle, one of our reader favorites, and if you want more options, check out my straight-leg jeans roundup.

On top, I’m using the Italian Wool Oversized Blazer from Quince. I’m getting really tired of seeing blazers priced at $400 or $500, so finding a wool option for around $100 is refreshing. This one is designed to be slightly oversized, so keep that in mind when choosing your size.

Now, I really want you to notice how good the black and brown look together. It’s one of my favorite color combinations, and so much more interesting than automatically reaching for a black or gray blazer. The brown warms up the whole outfit.

For shoes, I’m using The Pointe in Dune and Black from Margaux. These two-tone cap-toe ballet flats tie the colors together. Margaux is an investment brand, but they’re currently having a rare 20% off sale.

I finished with an oversized black clutch from Quince and a tortoiseshell headband from J.Crew. Don’t overspend on the headband. It’s just a fun little detail that adds some personality. All together, this is something I’d wear for lunch with friends, a casual holiday get-together, or any day I want to look nice without being particularly dressed up.

Style Note

The proportions are important here. The fitted turtleneck balances the oversized blazer, while the straight-leg jeans keep the outfit relaxed. And notice how the tortoiseshell headband and cap-toe flats pick up the black and brown throughout the look.

You can also swap the ankle-length jeans for a full-length pair. If you do, I’d trade the ballet flats for a sleek black ankle boot, which works better with the longer hem.

Look 2: A Black Turtleneck With a Green Dupioni Skirt

Black turtleneck tucked into a green Tuckernuck dupioni skirt, with a Tuckernuck clutch, green drop earrings from Nordstrom and Sam Edelman suede slingbacks
Ripley Rader Black Modal Turtleneck, $128 | Tuckernuck Green Dupioni Kendall Skirt, $248 | Tuckernuck Black Satin Gabrielle Clutch, $98 | Erin McDermott Emerald Green Drop Earrings, $28 (reg. $58) | Sam Edelman Bianka Slingback Pump, $150

For this next look, we’re going bold with a green dupioni skirt from Tuckernuck. I have this skirt, and it’s even prettier in person. The green is a true holiday color, and the fabric has a lot of volume and sheen. What you can’t see in the picture is that it has an elastic waistband in the back, which makes it surprisingly comfortable.

And while it’s definitely a statement piece, I think you can wear it to more events than you might expect, especially with simple basics. We go to a Santa brunch every year, and the women tend to get dressed up. This would be such a fun outfit for something like that.

Tuck your black turtleneck into the skirt and add this reader-favorite clutch, also from Tuckernuck. Tuckernuck bags are funny. They’re either $98 or $600, and luckily, this one is the former.

For earrings, you’d be surprised how difficult it was to find green, dangly costume earrings at an actual costume jewelry price. I eventually found these at Nordstrom, on sale for $28. That’s about what I’d want to spend on something like this, and as always, look through what you already own first.

Finally, I added simple suede slingbacks from Sam Edelman. We use these all the time because they’re so versatile. If you already have a pair of suede pumps, wear those instead.

Style Note

The easiest way to make a dramatic skirt more wearable is to keep everything else simple. Tuck your turtleneck in completely to define your waist and balance the volume of the skirt. The green makes enough of a statement on its own, so you only need a little sparkle from your earrings to finish the look.

Look 3: A Black Turtleneck With Bronze Metallic Pants

Black turtleneck with Banana Republic Factory bronze metallic wide-leg pants, Margaux Brera Boots, a bronze Dillard's clutch and a Sterling Forever chocolate brown ring
Ripley Rader Black Modal Turtleneck, $128 | Banana Republic Factory Wide-Leg High-Rise Metallic Pant, $44 (reg. $110) | Margaux The Brera Boot, $396 (reg. $495) | Cezanne Felicity Knot Minaudiere Clutch at Dillard’s, $52.50 (reg. $70) | Sterling Forever Mini Chocolate Elongated Cushion Ring, $143 (reg. $179)

For our last look, I was so excited to find these bronze metallic pants from Banana Republic Factory. Every now and then they get something really special at a Factory price, and these are a perfect example. Right now, they’re $44 with an extra 20% off, and they come in regular and petite sizes, 24 to 35.

They’re high-waisted with a wide leg, so our fitted black turtleneck works perfectly with them. And we’re mixing black and brown again, this time with a little metallic shine, which makes the combination even more interesting.

The pants are intentionally cropped, which is why I’m showing The Brera Boot from Margaux, also currently 20% off. These have a higher shaft that sits nicely underneath the hem of cropped pants, so you don’t end up with an awkward gap between your pants and boots. For an under $100 option, try this pair from Nine West.

For a bag, I found this simple bronze clutch at Dillard’s, currently on sale for $52. It picks up the metallic finish of the pants without making the outfit feel too matchy.

And just for fun, I added a chocolate brown CZ ring from Sterling Forever. I have a few of their rings, and they’re an easy way to dress up an outfit without spending a fortune. They’re also having their Black Friday sale, with 20% off. I love this whole look for dinner out, cocktails with friends, or a holiday party when you want to wear something festive but aren’t in the mood for a dress.

Style Note

With high-waisted, wide-leg pants, you want to define your waist, so tuck your turtleneck in completely. And because these pants are cropped, your footwear matters. A higher-shaft ankle boot creates a continuous line underneath the hem, which is especially flattering with this silhouette.

You don’t need a new wardrobe for the holidays. Start with the black turtleneck you already own and build your outfit by giving it one thing it hasn’t been paired with before, whether that’s a brown blazer, a green skirt, or a pair of bronze pants.

Shop this Post

Want everything I recommend in one place?

Shop my trusted recommendations

ShopMy is where I save and organize the pieces I consistently recommend, including wardrobe staples, standout finds, and brands I have researched, worn, or genuinely trust. Everything here reflects my years of experience in personal style and the same thoughtful approach I use across The Well Dressed Life.

If you are looking for something specific, or want reliable options without the overwhelm, this is where I start.

Browse my ShopMy

Related Articles

Pages from The Modern Wardrobe Essentials Checklist

Get every new post in your inbox

Sign up to get an email when my daily post goes live. As a thank you, I’ll send you The Modern Wardrobe Essentials Checklist.

Be the first to comment on: "Your Black Turtleneck Is More Interesting Than You Think: 3 Ways to Wear It This Holiday Season"

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.