September Reader Favorites

Ah, early fall—there’s something about this season that feels both refreshing and familiar, even when we’re wearing timeless pieces. The change in weather brings new opportunities to step out, socialize, and show off our favorite styles.

As we head into October, let’s take a moment to highlight the standout best sellers from September. From two pairs of budget-friendly jeans that fit like a dream to luxe designer flats at 60% off, stylish layers that look high-end, and plenty of fresh tops—there’s no shortage of fabulous finds to elevate your fall wardrobe!

September Reader Faves

High-Waisted Wow Straight Ankle Jeans

I’ve tried just about every slim straight jean on the market, including styles from some of my favorite high-end brands. As someone who’s always willing to invest in quality denim, I was genuinely surprised to find that my favorite pair is the High-Waisted Wow Straight Ankle Jeans from Old Navy—currently priced at only $14!

Every other pair I tried had something slightly off—whether it was too tight in the leg, too wide, too short, or an unnecessary detail that made a classic feel too trendy. But these jeans hit the mark perfectly.

I bought them in dark, medium, and light wash. At 5’10”, the regular length falls exactly where I want it, making them perfect for pairing with flats and sneakers.

10/10—perfect fit, no notes!

You can see me in them here.

High-Waisted Wow Straight Ankle Jeans

Old Navy

$15

Regular, Petite, Tall
0 – 30

Buy Now

Scuba Fitted Top

If you’re on the hunt for work-appropriate tops, consider the Scuba Fitted Top from Banana Republic Factory.

It’s available in wine (pictured), navy, white, and black—all for just $25.

What I love most is the subtle top-stitching that adds a touch of interest, along with the elbow-length sleeves, a feature my readers are always asking for.

Scuba Fitted Top

Banana Republic Factory

$25

XXS -XXL

Buy Now

Soft Luxe Turtleneck Top

Another great option from Banana Republic Factory is their Soft Luxe Turtleneck Top.

I’m definitely a turtleneck girl come fall—I love them as a stand-alone piece or as a perfect base layer.

This style, made from an incredibly soft yet sustainable fabric, strikes the ideal balance between elegance and casual comfort. Dress it up with faux leather or coated trousers and heels, or you can also keep it relaxed with ankle-skimming jeans and ballet flats.

With plenty of color choices, it’s an absolute steal at just $20, plus an extra 20% off—making it even more affordable than some Amazon options!

Soft Luxe Turtleneck Top

Banana Republic Factory

$20.00

XXS – XXL

Buy Now

CashSoft Cable-Knit Crewneck Sweater

I recently bought the CashSoft Cable-Knit Crewneck Sweater from Gap Factory, and I’ve already worn it several times.

It’s become a key piece in my early fall uniform—jeans, flats or sneakers, and a simple sweater. Sometimes, I’ll also layer a white tee underneath for added dimension. Add a few pieces of everyday jewelry, and you’ve got an effortlessly polished look without much effort.

Made from a soft cotton blend, it’s great quality for just $35.99, and it also comes in a range of classic neutrals.

CashSoft Cable-Knit Crewneck Sweater

Gap Factory

$29.99

Buy Now

Gabby Ballet Flat

I’ve always had a soft spot for designer shoes. While my life no longer supports a closet full of them, scoring a pair I love at a deep discount still brings me the kind of joy I used to get from shopping when I was younger—back when I was pretending not to be broke!

The Gabby Ballet Flat from Stuart Weitzman might just be the find of the season. Originally $395, they’re now marked down to $158, featuring the classic and on-trend cap toe design. These flats are buttery soft and incredibly comfortable.

They’re also available in sleek all black, fitting true to size.

Gabby Ballet Flat

Stuart Weitzman

$158.00

Buy Now

Striped Sequin Sweater

Daytime sequins take me right back to the early 2000s, in the best way possible.

So, I was thrilled to see so many of you grab this Striped Sequin Sweater from LOFT. It’s absolutely adorable!

While sequins might seem like a statement piece, this sweater is surprisingly versatile. I can already envision it styled multiple ways, both now and into the holiday season. Pair it with light-wash jeans and black flats for a casual midweek dinner, with dark wash or black jeans and heels for drinks at a friend’s house, or elevate it with a black silk midi skirt and strappy heels for a holiday party.

This one’s sure to sell out, so grab it while sizes are still available!

Striped Sequin Sweater

LOFT

$62.96

XXS – XXL

Buy Now

Relaxed Shirt Jacket

While jackets are always a fall staple, this year they’re exceptionally good.

That’s likely because we’ve finally moved away from the long, oversized styles and returned to more tailored, classic fits. These give us greater versatility and extend the life of each piece.

Take the Relaxed Shirt Jacket from Old Navy, for example—, one of September’s top sellers, it’s replacing the “shacket” trend, and I couldn’t be happier!

Hitting right at the hips, this style is perfect for maintaining the illusion of longer legs, which is especially great if you’re on the shorter side. The beige option (which actually reads more like ivory) looks wonderfully elevated, and it’s priced under $50—a total win for fall.

Relaxed Shirt Jacket

Old Navy

$44.99

Regular, Tall and Petite
XS – 4X

Buy Now

Vegan Leather Quilted Jacket

Let’s take a moment to celebrate the Vegan Leather Quilted Jacket from Banana Republic Factory.

Are you kidding me?

If you told me this jacket was priced at $400 on Tuckernuck, I wouldn’t have blinked—that would feel totally fair for something this chic. But at only $100 on BRF, it’s an absolute steal! With its luxurious quilted design and sleek vegan leather, it looks far more expensive than it is.

It’s no surprise it’s flying off the shelves. Currently, it’s only available in sizes XS, S, and M—so if you’re thinking about it, act fast before it’s gone!

Vegan Leather Quilted Jacket

Banana Republic Factory

$100.00

XXS – XXL

Buy Now

Mid Rise Baby Boot Jeans

The Gap Factory Mid Rise Baby Boot Jeans have been a reader favorite for over a year, so it’s always exciting to see them make a comeback on our Best Sellers list.

The fit is fantastic, and the price is unbeatable! Plus, they offer sizes ranging from 24 to 35 in regular, short, and long lengths, ensuring a great fit for everyone.

I am 5’10 and wear the regular length with ankle boots.

I recently repurchased these in medium wash and black in my new size, and I continue to be impressed by the quality for such a reasonable price.

Mid Rise Baby Boot Jeans

Gap Factory

$41.99

Buy Now

Blackwatch Saranac Shirt

Finally, the Blackwatch Saranac Shirt from Tuckernuck was a huge hit last month! Its seasonal yet unexpected print makes it perfect for the holidays, easily styled with jeans or your favorite black bottoms.

The soft gathering at the sleeves and the slim fit through the body add an updated elegance, while still keeping it casual—a combination I absolutely love.

Sizes are available, but limited, and it runs true to size, all for under $100 on sale. Don’t miss out!